AI Overviews Are Taking Over the Map Pack: My 12-Market Study

Published: November 19, 2026

Written By:

Browse The Content of this Article

If you’ve searched for your own business on Google lately, you’ve probably noticed it doesn’t look the way it used to.

For years, the goal in local search was pretty simple. You wanted to be one of the three businesses in that box near the top of the page, the one with the little map next to it. Get in there, and the phone rang.

But Google has started writing its own answer at the top of the page, and that answer recommends a handful of businesses right inside it.

Sometimes those three listings with the map still sit underneath.

And sometimes they’re just gone.

I kept running into this on searches for my own clients, and when I went looking for someone who had actually measured how often it was happening, I couldn’t find anyone. So I decided to measure it myself.

Over two months, I ran 480 local searches by hand.

Twelve markets, everywhere from Phoenix down to a town of 13,000 people in Missouri.

Ten different kinds of businesses, including home services, law firms, medical practices, and restaurants. Then I went back weeks later and ran every single search again, so I could see what had actually changed in between.

The first time through, Google wrote an AI answer on about four out of every ten searches. The second time through, it was nearly all of them. And in that last round, those three map listings had mostly disappeared. The businesses showed up inside the AI answer instead.

Here’s what that means if you own a local business: you can be ranking exactly where you’ve always wanted to rank, and still not be one of the businesses Google decides to recommend.

My full study is published on Semrush.

Semrush published the full study. It covers:

  • How quickly this shifted, and how far it went
  • What happened to those map listings when the AI answer took over
  • Why a third of the businesses Google recommended weren’t even showing up in the regular search results
  • Why searching “plumber in Dallas” and “I need a plumber in Dallas” can get you two completely different lists
  • Why having the most reviews didn’t turn out to be what decided it
  • What I’d actually do about it if this were your business

This is the kind of work behind how I handle AI visibility for the businesses we take on. And I’m still running the searches. 💪

Read it here: AI Overviews are taking over the map pack. Here’s what I found

Share This Blog

Facebook
LinkedIn
X

Contact Us

We're Here To Help